A botched nose job can support a lawsuit when the surgeon fell below accepted practice, or skipped a risk you should have been told about, and that caused a provable injury such as blocked breathing, collapse or a hole in the septum. A nose you simply dislike is rarely enough. In California you generally have one year from discovery or three years from surgery, whichever comes first (CCP 340.5).
Questions about your injury case?
Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.
Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win
When does a botched nose job become a malpractice case?
The law does not ask whether you are happy with your nose. California jurors are instructed that a practitioner is not necessarily negligent because the effort was unsuccessful, and is negligent only if less skillful, knowledgeable or careful than other reasonable practitioners of the same kind would have been in similar circumstances (CACI 505). On top of that breach, you must prove it caused your harm and that the harm is real (CACI 500). Washington uses the same building blocks: a failure to use the care, skill and learning of a reasonably prudent provider in that profession, and proof that the failure caused the injury (RCW 7.70.040).
That is why the injury matters so much in nose cases. A tip that looks slightly wide is a matter of taste. Blocked breathing on one side, a nose that sinks, a perforated septum or a spinal fluid leak can be examined and documented by a second surgeon. When that surgeon can also point to a step in the operative report that careful surgeons would not have taken, a cosmetic complaint becomes a provable injury.
Timing matters too. The tip can stay swollen and numb for months, and the final result may take a year or longer to show (MedlinePlus). Worsening breathing, a visible collapse or signs of infection should be checked right away.
What does the research say about breathing problems and collapse?
The figures below are published data from peer-reviewed studies, not predictions about your case. MedlinePlus lists loss of nasal support, contour deformities, worse breathing through the nose and the need for further surgery among the known risks of rhinoplasty (MedlinePlus).
- Adverse events (2020 data): a systematic review of 36 studies reported need for revision in 0 to 10.9 percent of patients, septal perforation in 0 to 2.6 percent, and airway obstruction requiring revision in 0 to 3 percent (Sharif-Askary et al., 2020).
- Revision rates (2016 data): among 175,842 septorhinoplasty patients in California, Florida and New York treated from 2005 to 2009, 3.1 percent of first-time patients had a revision, and 7.9 percent of those operated on for cosmetic deformity did (Spataro et al., 2016).
- Court decisions (2021 study data): a review of 23 published U.S. rhinoplasty malpractice court decisions from 1960 to 2018 found 20 decided for the surgeon, with poor appearance as the main factor (Ong et al., 2021).
Complications happen even with careful surgeons, so a complication alone proves little. Those court decisions are research data, not a forecast for any claim. A functional injury backed by a qualified surgeon’s opinion carries more weight.
Cosmetic rhinoplasty or septoplasty: does it change the claim or the insurance?
A septoplasty straightens the wall between the nostrils to relieve blockage, and breathing usually improves afterward (MedlinePlus, Septoplasty). The standard of care applies to the cosmetic and breathing parts alike, but the type of surgery shapes the proof and the bills.
Insurance often draws the line. California defines cosmetic surgery as reshaping normal structures to improve appearance, and lets health plans deny reconstructive surgery that offers only a minimal improvement in appearance (Health and Safety Code 1367.63). Medicare excludes cosmetic surgery except for prompt repair of an accidental injury or to improve the function of a malformed body part (42 CFR 411.15). If your plan refuses a repair because the first surgery was cosmetic, the cost of that repair can become part of your damages.
Were you told about the risk before the surgery?
A missing warning is a separate claim from careless surgery. In California you must show the surgeon did not disclose the important risks, that a reasonable person in your position would have refused if properly informed, and that you were harmed by a risk that should have been explained (CACI 533).
Texas spells out the warnings. Its Medical Disclosure Panel decides which risks must be disclosed for each procedure (Texas HHSC). For rhinoplasty, with or without septoplasty, the list includes new problems such as septal perforation or breathing difficulty, a spinal fluid leak, and a worse or unsatisfactory appearance (25 TAC 602.22). The only theory for a missing warning in Texas is negligence in failing to disclose (CPRC 74.101). In Washington, a fact is material if a reasonably prudent patient would attach significance to it, and you must show such a fact went unmentioned (RCW 7.70.050).
A signed form that names breathing difficulty answers the warning claim. It does not excuse surgery done carelessly, which is still judged against the standard of care.
Free case review
Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
How long do you have, and is there a cap?
| State | Deadline to file | Step before filing |
|---|---|---|
| California | Earlier of 1 year after discovery or 3 years after the injury (CCP 340.5) | Written notice at least 90 days ahead (CCP 364) |
| Texas | 2 years from the breach or the end of treatment, never more than 10 years (CPRC 74.251) | Certified-mail notice 60 days ahead with a records authorization (74.051) |
| Washington | Later of 3 years after the surgery or 1 year after discovery (RCW 4.16.350) | Talk to a lawyer early |
Washington’s statute still prints an eight-year outer limit, but the state Supreme Court struck it down on December 7, 2023 (Bennett v. United States). Texas adds a hurdle after filing: within 120 days of each defendant’s answer, you must serve a qualified physician’s written report and résumé (74.351).
California caps noneconomic damages, such as pain and disfigurement, in non-death cases at $350,000 for 2023, rising $40,000 each January toward $750,000; by our reading of the statute, the 2026 figure is $470,000 (Civil Code 3333.2). Repair surgery and lost earnings are economic losses and fall outside that cap. Texas limits noneconomic damages against physicians to $250,000 per claimant (74.301). California also limits the lawyer’s contingency fee in these cases to 25% if the case settles before suit and 33% after (B&P 6146).
What to do now
- Write down the surgery date and the day you first noticed trouble breathing or a change in shape.
- Keep a short daily log of breathing, nosebleeds, sleep and snoring.
- Ask the surgeon and the surgery center in writing for your full chart, including the operative report and photos.
- Get an exam from a surgeon who had no part in the first operation.
- Save the consent form, the quote, financing papers and every text or email with the office.
- Read any revision or refund agreement for release language before you sign.
- Call a lawyer before the notice periods eat into your filing deadline.
Talk to us about your nose surgery
If you are struggling to breathe or your nose has lost its shape after surgery, call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free, confidential review in English or Spanish. We will tell you honestly whether we see negligence or a disappointing result. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Common questions
Can I sue over a nose job I just don’t like?
Usually not. If the surgery was done as planned and the result is within what the consent form described, the law treats it as an unsatisfying outcome. A breathing problem, collapse or perforation tied to a surgical error is different.
Will a revision rhinoplasty hurt my case?
It can change the evidence, because the second surgeon may remove or rebuild what the first one left. Get your records and photos, and have the revising surgeon document what was found during the repair.
Does it matter whether a plastic surgeon or an ENT did my surgery?
The surgeon is compared with reasonable practitioners of the same kind (CACI 505). Both specialties perform nose surgery, so the reviewing physician should match the field of the surgeon who operated.
Do you handle Texas cases?
Yes. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou.
Ask a question
Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.
Can't breathe right after your nose job? Ask us. — Beverly Law
Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Related pages
Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · Do you need an expert witness in Washington? · Beverly Hills medical malpractice lawyer · Lawsuit funding on a medical malpractice case · Law Blog
Talk to our team today
Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.
Sources
- MedlinePlus, Nose reshaping (rhinoplasty)
- MedlinePlus en español, Rinoplastia
- MedlinePlus, Septoplasty
- MedlinePlus en español, Septoplastia
- Sharif-Askary et al., Incidence of Postoperative Adverse Events after Rhinoplasty: A Systematic Review, Plast Reconstr Surg 2020 (PubMed)
- Spataro et al., Revision Rates and Risk Factors of 175 842 Patients Undergoing Septorhinoplasty, JAMA Facial Plast Surg 2016 (PubMed)
- Ong et al., Characterization of Medical Malpractice Litigation After Rhinoplasty in the United States, Aesthet Surg J 2021 (PubMed)
- 42 CFR 411.15, Medicare exclusions (cosmetic surgery, paragraph h)
- Cal. Health and Safety Code 1367.63
- CACI No. 500, Medical Negligence: Essential Factual Elements
- CACI No. 505, Success Not Required
- CACI No. 533, Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Essential Factual Elements
- Cal. Civil Code 3333.2
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 364
- Cal. Business and Professions Code 6146
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.051, 74.101, 74.251, 74.301, 74.351)
- 25 Tex. Admin. Code 602.22, plastic surgery and integumentary system (List A, rhinoplasty)
- Texas HHSC, Texas Medical Disclosure Panel
- RCW 4.16.350
- RCW 7.70.040
- RCW 7.70.050
- Bennett v. United States, No. 101300-1 (Wash. Dec. 7, 2023)
Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

