Cosmetic surgery malpractice cases in the published court records are won or lost on proof: a qualified physician usually must explain what the surgeon did wrong, and the claim must be filed on time. In California that generally means within one year of discovering the injury and no later than three years after it (CCP 340.5).
Questions about your injury case?
Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.
Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win
Which plastic surgery malpractice cases reached a verdict or an appeal?
Each appellate case below links to the opinion. Records reviewed November 13, 2026. These amounts are what courts recorded in other people’s cases. They are not a prediction of what any other claim is worth, and they are not Beverly Law’s cases.
| Year | State | Procedure | Case and number | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | WA | Liposuction, tummy tuck, breast lift | Elmi v. Aesthetic Rejuvenation Spa, No. 85851-3-I | $13,034,186 judgment on the verdict affirmed |
| 2025 | CA | Liposuction procedure | Garland v. Pacific Lipo, No. B336682 | Summary judgment affirmed: no physician declaration |
| 2023 | CA | Brazilian butt lift (death) | Leon v. Hughes, No. B307344 | Verdict for the family set aside; new trial ordered |
| 2022 | CA | Breast augmentation (death) | Divino Plastic Surgery v. Superior Court, No. D079661 | Punitive damages claim blocked as late |
| 2021 | TX | Breast lift and implant removal | Nikko Cosmetic Surgery Center v. Carroll, No. 01-20-00752-CV | Physician report upheld; case goes on |
| 2020 | CA | Face, neck and eyelid lift | Doe v. Marten, No. A153427 | Jury award of about $6.7 million reinstated |
| 2019 | WA | Breast lift, liposuction, tummy tuck | Boyer v. Morimoto, No. 36166-7-III | Dismissal affirmed: witness did not show Washington standard |
| 2012 | TX | Liposuction | Marino v. Wilkins, No. 01-11-00835-CV | Motion to dismiss denied; affirmed |
| 2007 | TX | Breast implants | Hunsucker v. Fustok, No. 01-06-00066-CV | Dismissed for no physician report; patient owed fees |
| 2006 | TX | Liposuction and thigh lift | Mills v. Pate, No. 08-04-00335-CV | Consent claims too late; promise claim revived |
What did the California cases decide?
In Doe v. Marten, a San Francisco jury awarded $3,676,780 in economic damages and $3,000,000 in noneconomic damages after face, neck and eyelid surgery, and found the patient 5% at fault. The trial judge threw the verdict out as filed too late. The Court of Appeal reversed in 2020 because the surgeon’s response to her arbitration demand led her to pursue arbitration first, and it ordered judgment entered on the verdict (No. A153427).
In Leon v. Hughes, a Los Angeles jury found a surgeon negligent in a 2014 Brazilian butt lift that ended in death and awarded $3 million in noneconomic damages, which the court cut to $250,000 under the cap then in force. The trial judge then ruled against the family on causation and granted a new trial. In 2023 the Court of Appeal held the evidence did support causation but upheld the new trial order, so the case went back for a new trial (No. B307344).
Two other California records turned on procedure. In Divino Plastic Surgery, the family of a woman who died after breast augmentation lost its punitive damages claim because the motion to add it came later than CCP 425.13 allows: within two years of filing and at least nine months before the first trial date. In Garland, a patient who sued without a lawyer filed no physician declaration against the clinic’s medical witness, and her consent forms said no particular outcome was promised, so summary judgment for the clinic stood.
What did the Texas and Washington cases decide?
Most Texas records here are fights over the physician report that Texas requires within 120 days after each defendant answers. Without it, on the doctor’s motion the court must dismiss the claim for good and award the doctor fees (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 74.351). That happened in Hunsucker under the older rule. In Marino and Nikko the motions to dismiss failed and the patients could keep going. In Nikko the patient alleged she agreed to a breast lift and implant removal but received a breast reduction with her implants left in.
Mills v. Pate split a liposuction case. Consent claims about the first surgery came too late, and the second surgery’s risks were disclosed in writing. But the patient said the doctor told her she would look beautiful with smooth skin, and the court revived that promise claim and sent it back to the trial court.
In Washington, a King County jury found Dr. Kristine Brecht and her clinic liable to Nasra Elmi on every claim, including medical negligence and lack of informed consent, after two surgeries in September 2020. The verdict was $11,000,000 for her and $2,000,000 for her husband, and judgment was entered for $13,034,186. The Court of Appeals affirmed on July 21, 2025, and the defense asked the state Supreme Court to review it (petition No. 104620-1). The Supreme Court denied review on January 6, 2026 (order list). By contrast, Boyer v. Morimoto ended before trial because the patient’s medical witness did not show he knew the Washington standard of care.
How do damage caps change a plastic surgery verdict?
A jury’s number is not always the judgment. California caps noneconomic damages in medical negligence. For cases filed on or after January 1, 2023, the cap started at $350,000 for injury and $500,000 for death, rising each year until it reaches $750,000 and $1,000,000 (Civil Code 3333.2). In 2026 those figures are $470,000 and $650,000. Texas limits noneconomic damages against physicians to $250,000 per claimant (74.301). These noneconomic caps do not limit medical bills, revision surgery or lost income, although Texas has a separate overall limit in death cases (74.303).
Free case review
Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
How can you check a surgeon’s record yourself?
California’s Medical Board must post malpractice judgments and arbitration awards in any amount, and some settlements of $30,000 or more when a doctor has several in ten years (B&P 803.1). Search a doctor through the Medical Board of California, the Texas Medical Board or the Washington Department of Health. In Elmi, the jury heard about Washington Medical Commission disciplinary orders.
What to do now
- Ask for your operative report, anesthesia record, consent forms and every photo the clinic took.
- Write down the date you first suspected the surgery caused the problem. Washington generally allows three years from the surgery or one year from discovery, whichever is later (RCW 4.16.350). Texas generally allows two years (74.251).
- Read anything the clinic asks you to sign before you accept a refund or a free revision.
- Look up the surgeon’s board record using the links above.
- Have a lawyer review the records early, since a qualified physician generally has to support the claim in all three states.
Talk to us about your surgery
If your cosmetic surgery left you with an injury that needs correcting, call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free review of your records and your deadline. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Common questions
Are cosmetic surgery malpractice cases hard to win?
Several cases above ended because the patient lacked a physician’s support or filed late, not because a court approved the surgery.
Can a jury verdict be taken away after trial?
Yes. A trial judge can set aside a verdict or order a new trial, and an appeal can restore or reverse it. Doe v. Marten got her award back on appeal; the family in Leon v. Hughes won at trial and still had to try the case again.
Can I sue if my surgeon promised a certain result?
Sometimes. In Mills v. Pate a Texas court let a claim go forward on a doctor’s promise about how the patient would look. In Garland, signed forms saying no outcome was promised helped defeat the claim. What you signed matters as much as what you were told.
Does a lack of informed consent count as malpractice?
It can. In Washington a patient must show the provider failed to disclose a material fact, a reasonable patient would have refused treatment if told, and the treatment caused the injury (RCW 7.70.050). The Elmi jury found a lack of informed consent along with negligence.
Why are there no Beverly Law results on this page?
This page reports only public court records from other patients’ cases. Past results do not predict yours.
Ask a question
Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.
Find out what the court records mean for your surgery — Beverly Law
Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Related pages
Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Beverly Hills medical malpractice lawyer · MICRA in 2026: what the cap does and does not limit · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · Do you need a medical witness to sue in Washington? · Law Blog
Talk to our team today
Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.
Sources
- Doe v. Marten, Cal. Court of Appeal, No. A153427 (2020)
- Divino Plastic Surgery v. Superior Court, Cal. Court of Appeal, No. D079661 (2022)
- Leon v. Hughes, Cal. Court of Appeal, No. B307344 (2023)
- Garland v. Pacific Lipo, Cal. Court of Appeal, No. B336682 (2025)
- Mills v. Pate, Tex. App. El Paso, No. 08-04-00335-CV (2006)
- Hunsucker v. Fustok, Tex. App. Houston [1st Dist.], No. 01-06-00066-CV (2007)
- Marino v. Wilkins, Tex. App. Houston [1st Dist.], No. 01-11-00835-CV (2012)
- Nikko Cosmetic Surgery Center v. Carroll, Tex. App. Houston [1st Dist.], No. 01-20-00752-CV (2021)
- Boyer v. Morimoto, Wash. Court of Appeals, No. 36166-7-III (2019)
- Elmi v. Aesthetic Rejuvenation Spa, Wash. Court of Appeals, No. 85851-3-I (2025)
- Petition for review, Washington Supreme Court No. 104620-1 (Elmi)
- Washington Supreme Court, petitions for review considered January 6, 2026 (No. 104620-1 denied)
- KING 5, Burien cosmetic surgeon to appeal verdict
- Cal. Civil Code 3333.2 (noneconomic damages limits)
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5 (deadline)
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 425.13 (punitive damages against health care providers)
- Cal. Business and Professions Code 803.1 (what the Medical Board discloses)
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.251, 74.301, 74.303, 74.351)
- RCW 4.16.350 (Washington deadline)
- RCW 7.70.050 (Washington informed consent)
- Medical Board of California, License verification
- Texas Medical Board, Look up a license
- Washington Department of Health, Provider credential search
Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

