Beverly Law — Accident AttorneysBEVERLY LAW INJURY ATTORNEYS
PLASTIC SURGERY MALPRACTICE

Breast Implant Lawsuit: Surgeon Malpractice or a Claim Against the Implant Maker

Michael Shemtoub, trial attorney, Beverly Law
Michael Shemtoub, Beverly Law
Trial attorney · English y Español · (310) 552-6959

A breast implant lawsuit is usually one of two claims: malpractice against the surgeon, for errors such as the wrong size or placement or an infection left untreated, or a product claim against the maker, such as one tied to the recalled textured implants linked to BIA-ALCL. In California, malpractice generally must be filed within one year of discovery and three years of injury (CCP 340.5).

Questions about your injury case?

Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.

Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win

Is my problem a surgeon claim or an implant claim?

The two claims have different defendants, proof and deadlines.

Surgical malpracticeProduct claim
Who is suedThe surgeon, the clinic or surgery centerThe implant manufacturer or seller
Typical problemsWrong size or placement, untreated infection, contracture handled poorly, risks never explainedA defect in the implant itself, an inadequate warning, BIA-ALCL tied to a recalled textured model
What must be shownCare below the accepted standard, or a missing disclosure, that caused harmA manufacturing defect, a design defect or a failure to warn (CACI 1200)
Biggest hurdleSeparating a known risk from negligenceFederal preemption for FDA-approved devices

A disappointing look is not, by itself, either claim. Texas’s official disclosure list for augmentation includes “worsening or unsatisfactory appearance including asymmetry (unequal size or shape)” and capsular contracture as known risks (25 TAC 602.22). A claim needs proof that something went wrong in the care or in the device.

When is a bad implant result surgical malpractice?

The FDA lists more than two dozen local complications, including infection, malposition and pain, and says implants “are not considered lifetime devices” (FDA). Facts that call for a closer look at the surgeon’s work:

  • Wrong size or placement. Implants far from the size you agreed to in writing, or placed so badly that a second surgery is needed, suggest a planning or technique error.
  • Infection. Fever or drainage you reported that went untreated for days is a care question, separate from the infection itself.
  • Capsular contracture. The FDA describes it as hardening of the breast around the implant, with grades III and IV considered severe. Contracture happens after careful surgery too; the question is how it was recognized and treated.
  • Risks never explained. California physicians must give written information on silicone implants before surgery and note it in the chart (B&P 2259; Medical Board of California). Since October 27, 2021, the FDA has required a patient decision checklist that the provider reviews with you and the implanting physician signs (FDA).

Informed consent is its own claim in each state. California asks whether a reasonable person would have refused the surgery if told the important risks (CACI 533). Texas presumes a negligent failure to disclose, a presumption the doctor can rebut, when a risk on the official list was not disclosed (CPRC 74.106). Washington requires proof that a material fact went undisclosed and a reasonably prudent patient would have declined (RCW 7.70.050).

What was the textured implant recall, and what is BIA-ALCL?

BIA-ALCL is a type of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, usually found in the scar tissue and fluid near the implant, and the FDA says the risk is higher with textured implants than smooth ones (FDA). Signs include persistent swelling, a lump or pain near the implant, often years after surgery.

On July 24, 2019, the FDA asked Allergan to recall its BIOCELL textured breast implants and tissue expanders, and the company agreed to a worldwide recall. The FDA found the BIA-ALCL risk with those implants was about six times that of other makers’ textured implants (FDA). Its smooth and MICROCELL products were not affected (FDA recall notice). The FDA does not recommend removing implants from patients without symptoms.

The FDA’s medical device report data, as of June 30, 2024, list 1,380 BIA-ALCL cases and 64 deaths; 1,010 involved textured implants and 1,182 named Allergan (FDA MDR data). These are reports, not proof that any one implant caused any one illness.

Can you sue the implant maker? Preemption is the main obstacle

California recognizes product claims for a manufacturing defect, a design defect and a failure to warn (CACI 1200). For prescription products, the warning goes to the prescribing physician (CACI 1205).

Federal law limits many of these claims. Breast implants sold in the U.S. go through FDA premarket approval, and the FDA’s sale restrictions sit in those approval letters (FDA). The Supreme Court held that federal law “bars common-law claims challenging the safety or effectiveness” of a device marketed in the form the FDA approved (Riegel v. Medtronic). The Court also said states may still provide a damages remedy for claims premised on a violation of FDA regulations, where state duties “parallel” federal ones (opinion). In practice, a claim that the approved design or label should have been different usually fails; a claim that the maker departed from its approved specifications may survive.

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win

Ruptured implants and silicone cancer claims

Rupture is a tear or hole in the implant shell, and a silicone rupture can be silent, with no symptoms, so the FDA calls MRI the most effective way to find a silent rupture (FDA). FDA labeling guidance recommends the first screening ultrasound or MRI at 5 to 6 years after surgery, then every 2 to 3 years (FDA guidance). A rupture can support a claim when it came from a defect or surgical damage to the shell, or was ignored after you reported it.

For cancer, the FDA has reports of squamous cell carcinoma and other lymphomas in the capsule and continues to study them. It has “not detected any association” between silicone implants and connective tissue disease.

How long do I have, and are damages capped?

StateMalpractice deadlineProduct claim deadline
California1 year from discovery, 3 years at most, after 90 days’ notice (CCP 340.5, CCP 364)2 years for personal injury (CCP 335.1)
Texas2 years, 10-year outer limit; 60-day notice (CPRC 74.251, 74.051)2 years, and generally within 15 years of sale, with a narrow exception for latent disease (CPRC 16.003, 16.012)
Washington3 years from the act or 1 year from discovery, whichever is later (RCW 4.16.350)3 years from discovering the harm and its cause (RCW 7.72.060)

Washington’s eight-year medical outer limit was struck down on December 7, 2023 (Bennett v. United States). California caps noneconomic damages against health care providers, such as the surgeon and an office surgery center, at $470,000 combined in 2026 (Civil Code 3333.2); Texas caps them at $250,000 per claimant against physicians and requires a doctor’s report within 120 days of each answer (CPRC 74.301, 74.351). Those malpractice caps do not apply to a claim against the manufacturer.

What to do now

  1. Find your implant card, or ask the surgery center for the implant stickers and lot numbers.
  2. Request your full chart: consult notes, size discussions, the operative report, the signed checklist and every consent form.
  3. If the implant or capsule is removed, ask in writing that both be kept and sent to pathology.
  4. Get an independent opinion from a board-certified plastic surgeon and, for swelling or a lump, the imaging the FDA describes.
  5. Report the problem to the FDA through MedWatch.
  6. Do not sign a release for a free revision before a lawyer reads it.

Talk to us about your implant injury

Bring your implant card and records. Call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free, confidential review in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

Common questions

Do I need a breast implant lawyer for each claim?

One firm can review both. The malpractice claim is reviewed first because its deadlines are often shortest, and the device facts decide whether a product claim is open despite preemption.

I have textured implants but no symptoms. Can I sue?

Usually not yet. The FDA does not recommend removal without symptoms, and a claim needs an injury.

Can I sue for a ruptured silicone implant?

Possibly, if the rupture came from a defect, from damage during surgery, or was missed after you reported symptoms. Old age of the implant alone is rarely enough.

Do you handle Texas cases?

Yes. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou.

Ask a question

Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.

BEVERLY LAW · INJURY ATTORNEYS

Problems with your breast implants? Ask us which claim fits your case. — Beverly Law

Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

✓Free consultation✓No fees or costs unless we win✓English y Español✓Available 24/7

Related pages

Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · Do you need a medical witness to sue in Washington? · Injury deadlines in California, Texas and Washington · Lawsuit funding on a medical malpractice case · Law Blog

Talk to our team today

Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.

No fees or costs unless we win

Sources

  1. FDA, Risks and complications of breast implants
  2. FDA, Breast implant associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL)
  3. FDA, Medical device reports of BIA-ALCL (data as of June 30, 2024)
  4. FDA press announcement, July 24, 2019: FDA requests Allergan voluntarily recall certain breast implants and tissue expanders
  5. FDA recall notice: Allergan voluntarily recalls BIOCELL textured breast implants and tissue expanders
  6. FDA, Things to consider before getting breast implants (October 27, 2021 actions, patient decision checklist)
  7. FDA, Breast implant surgery (patient device card)
  8. FDA, Breast implants (restrictions on sale and distribution, MedWatch reporting)
  9. FDA guidance, Breast Implants: Certain Labeling Recommendations to Improve Patient Communication (September 29, 2020)
  10. Medical Board of California, Silicone implants information
  11. Cal. Business and Professions Code 2259
  12. CACI 1200, Strict Liability: Essential Factual Elements
  13. CACI 1203, Strict Liability: Design Defect, Consumer Expectation Test
  14. CACI 1205, Strict Liability: Failure to Warn
  15. Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc., 552 U.S. 312 (2008), syllabus
  16. Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc., opinion of the Court
  17. CACI 533, Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Essential Factual Elements
  18. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5
  19. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 364
  20. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 335.1
  21. Cal. Civil Code 3333.2
  22. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.051, 74.101, 74.106, 74.251, 74.301, 74.351)
  23. 25 Tex. Admin. Code 602.22 (augmentation mammoplasty)
  24. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 16 (16.003, 16.012)
  25. RCW 7.70.050
  26. RCW 4.16.350
  27. Bennett v. United States, No. 101300-1 (Wash. Dec. 7, 2023)
  28. RCW 7.72.060

Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

×

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win
© 2026 Beverly Law. All rights reserved. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Free consultation
No fees or costs unless we win
Call Now · 24/7
4.8 out of 5 · 604 Google reviews
Skip to content