Beverly Law — Accident AttorneysBEVERLY LAW INJURY ATTORNEYS

Can I Sue If My Surgery Didn't Work?

Michael Shemtoub, trial attorney, Beverly Law
Michael Shemtoub, Beverly Law
Trial attorney · English y Español · (310) 552-6959

You can sue if the surgeon fell below the accepted standard of care or did not warn you of a risk that then happened; a disappointing result alone is not enough. In California you generally have one year from discovering the injury or three years from the injury, whichever comes first (CCP 340.5), plus 90 days’ notice before filing (CCP 364).

Questions about your injury case?

Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.

Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win

Is a bad surgery result the same as malpractice?

No. California juries are told that a doctor is not necessarily negligent just because treatment failed or because a judgment call turned out wrong, as long as it was a reasonable call at the time (CACI 505). The question is whether the surgeon used the skill, knowledge and care that other reasonably careful surgeons in the same field would have used in similar circumstances (CACI 502).

Washington asks the same thing in its own words: did the provider fail to use the care, skill and learning expected of a reasonably prudent provider in the state, and did that failure cause the injury (RCW 7.70.040). Texas measures a surgeon against accepted standards of medical care, and the physician who testifies about them must meet the qualifications in section 74.401 (CPRC chapter 74).

Where is the line between a disappointing result and negligence?

Every surgery carries known risks, and cosmetic results depend partly on healing, skin and scar tissue the surgeon cannot control. The examples below are generic and show how a lawyer and a reviewing physician sort facts. They are Example only; the records and the testimony decide any real case.

Usually a disappointing result (Example only):

  • A patient wanted a smaller nose and got one, but finds it less refined than the photos she brought. The plan was sound and the surgery was done as planned.
  • After a tummy tuck, the scar heals wider than hoped. Wide scarring was on the signed consent form, and post-operative care followed the usual steps.
  • Liposuction leaves mild unevenness that the surgeon offers to touch up, a revision the consent form described as sometimes needed.

Possibly negligence (Example only):

  • An implant is placed in the wrong pocket or a size the patient never agreed to, and the operative report does not explain why.
  • A patient calls twice in the first week with fever, spreading redness and drainage, and the office tells her to wait without seeing her. The infection later requires removal of the implant.
  • A procedure is done in an office without the monitoring the patient’s health history called for, and the patient suffers an anesthesia injury.
  • A gauze sponge or instrument is left inside the body.

What separates the lists is a departure from accepted practice and an injury caused by it. In the second list, a reviewing surgeon can point to something that should have been done differently.

Can you sue for bad surgery if you were never warned of the risk?

Yes, in some cases. A separate claim exists when a surgeon fails to disclose the important risks and alternatives of a procedure. In California you must show that a reasonable person in your position would have declined the surgery if properly informed, and that the harm came from a risk that should have been explained (CACI 533).

Washington allows recovery for care the patient did not consent to, and also when a provider promised that the injury would not occur (RCW 7.70.030). Keep any message, brochure or consultation note in which the office told you a result was certain. Promises like that matter in cosmetic cases, where marketing can blur into medical advice.

Unhappy with plastic surgery results: what proof do you need?

Medical negligence cases are built on testimony from a qualified physician who explains the standard of care and how it was broken (CACI 502). Texas front-loads this step: within 120 days after each defendant files its answer, you must serve a written report from a qualified physician with a résumé, or the court must dismiss the claim against that defendant and award fees on its motion (CPRC 74.351).

The other proof is yours to collect:

  • Records. California providers must send copies within 15 days of a written request (Health and Safety Code 123110). Texas physicians must respond within 15 business days (Occupations Code 159.006). Washington providers have 15 working days, with a written extension of up to 21 working days (RCW 70.02.080). Ask for the operative report, anesthesia record, consent forms, photos the office took, and messages.
  • Photos. Dated photos before surgery, during healing and now, in the same lighting and angle, show change better than words.
  • A second opinion. A surgeon who did not do the first procedure can tell you what went wrong and what repair would involve.

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win

How long do you have, and what can you recover?

StateGeneral deadlineBefore filing
California1 year from discovery or 3 years from injury, whichever is first (CCP 340.5)90-day notice (CCP 364)
Texas2 years, with a 10-year outer limit (CPRC 74.251)60-day notice with a medical authorization (74.051)
Washington3 years from the act or 1 year from discovery, whichever is later (RCW 4.16.350)Ask a lawyer about current pre-suit steps

California and Washington stop the clock for a foreign object left in the body or for fraud or concealment. If the California notice is served in the last 90 days before the deadline, the deadline moves to 90 days after service.

Damages can include repair surgery, lost income and pain and suffering. California caps pain and suffering in non-death medical cases at $350,000 for 2023, rising $40,000 each January, which by our count of the statute puts it at $470,000 in 2026 (Civil Code 3333.2). Texas caps it at $250,000 per claimant against physicians (CPRC 74.301). California also limits a lawyer’s contingency fee in these cases to 25% before a lawsuit is filed and 33% after (B&P 6146).

What to do now

  1. Write down the date of surgery and the date you first suspected a problem.
  2. Request your complete records from the surgeon and the surgery center in writing.
  3. Photograph the area now, and gather your photos from before surgery.
  4. Get a second opinion before agreeing to a revision by the same surgeon.
  5. Save the consent forms, receipts, financing papers and every message with the office.
  6. Do not sign a release or refund agreement without reading what claims it gives up.
  7. Call a lawyer early, since notice periods run inside the filing deadline.

Talk to us about your surgery

If your surgery left you worse off and you want to know whether it crosses the line into negligence, call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free, confidential review in English or Spanish. We will tell you plainly if we think it is a disappointing result rather than a case. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

Common questions

Should I let the same surgeon do a revision?

That is your choice, and many revisions go well. Get your records and an independent opinion first, and read anything you are asked to sign with the revision, since some forms include a release.

Should I file a complaint with the medical board?

You can. The Medical Board of California investigates quality of care but does not pay compensation. Texas patients use the Texas Medical Board, and Washington patients the Department of Health. A complaint does not stop your filing deadline.

What if a med spa did the procedure?

In California, injections and lasers must be done by a physician, or by a registered nurse or physician assistant under a physician’s supervision, according to the Medical Board. Who held the needle can change who is responsible.

Do you handle Texas cases?

Yes. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou.

Ask a question

Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.

BEVERLY LAW · INJURY ATTORNEYS

Not sure if your result crosses the line? Ask us. — Beverly Law

Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

✓Free consultation✓No fees or costs unless we win✓English y Español✓Available 24/7

Related pages

Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · MICRA in 2026: what the cap does and does not limit · Do you need an expert witness in Washington? · Beverly Hills medical malpractice lawyer · Law Blog

Talk to our team today

Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.

No fees or costs unless we win

Sources

  1. CACI No. 500, Medical Negligence: Essential Factual Elements
  2. CACI No. 502, Standard of Care for Medical Specialists
  3. CACI No. 505, Success Not Required
  4. CACI No. 533, Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Essential Factual Elements
  5. Cal. Civil Code 3333.2
  6. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5
  7. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 364
  8. Cal. Business and Professions Code 6146
  9. Cal. Health and Safety Code 123110
  10. California Courts Self-Help, Statute of limitations
  11. California Courts Self-Help, Ley de prescripción (Spanish)
  12. Medical Board of California, Medical Spas
  13. Medical Board of California, Complaints
  14. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.051, 74.251, 74.301, 74.351, 74.401)
  15. Tex. Occupations Code chapter 159 (159.006)
  16. Texas Medical Board, Place a complaint
  17. RCW 7.70.030
  18. RCW 7.70.040
  19. RCW 4.16.350
  20. RCW 70.02.080
  21. Washington State Department of Health, File a complaint about a provider or facility

Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

×

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win
© 2026 Beverly Law. All rights reserved. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Free consultation
No fees or costs unless we win
Call Now · 24/7
4.8 out of 5 · 604 Google reviews
Skip to content