Beverly Law — Accident AttorneysBEVERLY LAW INJURY ATTORNEYS

Can You Sue a Plastic Surgeon for a Botched Surgery?

Michael Shemtoub, trial attorney, Beverly Law
Michael Shemtoub, Beverly Law
Trial attorney · English y Español · (310) 552-6959

Yes, you can sue a plastic surgeon when the surgery fell below what a reasonably careful plastic surgeon would have done and that failure injured you. A result you dislike is not enough by itself. In California the lawsuit is generally due one year from discovering the injury or three years from the injury, whichever comes first (CCP 340.5).

Questions about your injury case?

Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.

Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win

What four things must you prove to sue a plastic surgeon?

Lawyers use four words for a malpractice claim: duty, breach, causation and damages. California’s jury instruction folds them into three questions: was the defendant negligent, were you harmed, and was the negligence a substantial factor in causing the harm (CACI 400). If any one of the four is missing, the claim fails, however bad the outcome looks.

1. Duty. A surgeon who agrees to evaluate or operate on you owes you the level of skill, knowledge and care that other reasonably careful surgeons in the same field would use in similar circumstances (CACI 502). The harder question is usually who owed it: the surgeon, another doctor in the room, the anesthesia provider or the facility.

2. Breach. Negligence can be something a careful surgeon would not have done or something a careful surgeon would have done that yours did not (CACI 401). Jurors decide what the standard was from physician testimony, which can include the defendant’s own (CACI 501). Your photos show the outcome; a physician who reads the chart says what went wrong.

3. Causation. The breach must be a substantial factor in the harm: more than a remote or trivial contribution, though it need not be the only cause. Conduct is not a substantial factor if the same harm would have happened anyway (CACI 430). This is the element that sinks many cosmetic claims, because healing, smoking, weight change and known surgical risks all compete as explanations.

4. Damages. You must have a real loss: the cost of repair surgery, lost pay, and noneconomic harm such as pain, disfigurement, humiliation and loss of enjoyment of life. California jurors are told no fixed standard exists for valuing that last group (CACI 3905A).

How do Texas and Washington test the same four elements?

Texas makes you prove them on paper early. Within 120 days after each defendant files its original answer, you must serve a report from a qualified physician that fairly summarizes the applicable standards of care, how the care failed to meet them, and the causal link between that failure and your injury (CPRC 74.351). If no report is served on time, the court must dismiss the claim against that provider with prejudice and order you to pay its attorney’s fees when the provider asks.

Washington writes the test into its statute. You must show the provider did not exercise the degree of care, skill and learning expected of a reasonably prudent health care provider, and that this failure was a proximate cause of your injury (RCW 7.70.040). Proximate cause plays the role California gives to the substantial factor test.

Can you sue for bad plastic surgery if you only dislike the result?

Usually not. Every element above looks at what the surgeon did, and a disappointing shape or scar can follow a procedure done exactly right. Causation is often where the two separate.

Example only: two patients each have a breast lift wound that opens in the second week. The first patient’s surgeon closed the incision in the usual way, and she resumed smoking against written instructions; a reviewing surgeon may trace the problem to the smoking. The second patient reported fever and pus twice, and the office did not see her for nine days; a reviewing surgeon may find that delay a substantial factor in the tissue loss. The records decide any real case.

How long do you have, and do you have to warn the surgeon first?

California. File within one year of discovery or three years from the injury, whichever comes first, with the three-year limit extended only for fraud, intentional concealment or a foreign body left inside (CCP 340.5). The surgeon must get at least 90 days’ notice of the claim before suit, and a notice served in the last 90 days of the deadline extends it 90 days from service (CCP 364).

Texas. Two years from the breach or from the end of the treatment, and never more than 10 years after the act (CPRC 74.251). Written notice goes by certified mail at least 60 days before filing, with the required medical authorization, and proper notice tolls the deadline for 75 days (74.051).

Washington. Three years from the act or one year from when you discovered or should have discovered the injury, whichever is later (RCW 4.16.350). The statute still prints an eight-year outer limit, but the Washington Supreme Court held it unconstitutional on December 7, 2023 (Bennett v. United States).

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win

What can a botched surgery case recover, and what does a lawyer cost?

California caps only noneconomic damages. For a non-death case, all health care providers together share one cap, which began at $350,000 in 2023 and rises $40,000 every January 1, so the 2026 figure is $470,000 (health care institutions share a separate cap of the same size); the amount in effect on the date of judgment, award or settlement applies (Civil Code 3333.2). Texas limits noneconomic damages against physicians to $250,000 per claimant, with separate limits for institutions (CPRC 74.301). We found no cap in Washington: chapter 7.70 has none, and the general noneconomic limit was repealed in 2023 (RCW 4.56.250).

On fees, California allows a lawyer no more than 25% of a settlement signed before a complaint or arbitration demand is filed, and 33% after, unless a judge or arbitrator approves more after trial (B&P 6146). In Washington the court reviews whether each side’s fees are reasonable (RCW 7.70.070).

What to do now: four tasks for this week

  1. Ask for your records in writing. Request the full chart from the surgeon and the surgery center: consultation notes, consent forms, operative report, anesthesia record, nursing notes, office photos and messages. California providers must send copies within 15 days (Health and Safety Code 123110), Texas physicians by the 15th business day (Occupations Code 159.006), and Washington providers within 15 working days unless they explain a delay of up to 21 (RCW 70.02.080).
  2. Take photos today. Use daylight, the same angles each time, and a date on every file. Put your pre-surgery photos in the same folder.
  3. Book a second opinion. Choose a board-certified surgeon with no tie to the first practice. Ask what was done and what a repair involves, and keep the visit note.
  4. Put the deadline on your calendar. Write down the surgery date and the day you first suspected a problem, then count from the earlier rule above. Notice periods run inside that time, so call a lawyer before signing any refund, revision or release paper.

Ask us whether your surgery meets the four elements

If a cosmetic procedure left you injured, call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free, confidential review in English or Spanish. We will compare your records with each element and tell you plainly if we think it is a disappointing result rather than a claim. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

Common questions

Can I sue the surgery center or the anesthesia provider too?

Yes, if their own conduct meets the four elements. A center may be responsible for staffing, equipment or monitoring, and an anesthesia provider for sedation and recovery. Each defendant’s role is judged separately.

Do I need a lawyer to sue a plastic surgeon?

The law does not require one, but almost every case needs a qualified physician to testify about the standard of care, and Texas requires that physician’s report within 120 days of each answer. Missing those steps can end the case.

The surgeon offered a free revision. Should I accept?

That is your call. Get your records and an outside opinion first, and check any paper signed with the revision for release language.

Do you handle Texas cases?

Yes. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou.

Ask a question

Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.

BEVERLY LAW · INJURY ATTORNEYS

Find out if your surgery meets all four elements. — Beverly Law

Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

✓Free consultation✓No fees or costs unless we win✓English y Español✓Available 24/7

Related pages

Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · MICRA in 2026: what the cap does and does not limit · Do you need an expert witness in Washington? · Beverly Hills medical malpractice lawyer · Law Blog

Talk to our team today

Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.

No fees or costs unless we win

Sources

  1. CACI No. 400, Negligence: Essential Factual Elements
  2. CACI No. 401, Basic Standard of Care
  3. CACI No. 430, Causation: Substantial Factor
  4. CACI No. 501, Standard of Care for Health Care Professionals
  5. CACI No. 502, Standard of Care for Medical Specialists
  6. CACI No. 3905A, Physical Pain, Mental Suffering, and Emotional Distress
  7. Cal. Civil Code 3333.2
  8. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5
  9. Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 364
  10. Cal. Business and Professions Code 6146
  11. Cal. Health and Safety Code 123110
  12. California Courts Self-Help, Statute of limitations
  13. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.051, 74.251, 74.301, 74.351)
  14. Tex. Occupations Code chapter 159 (159.006)
  15. RCW 7.70.040
  16. RCW chapter 7.70 (section list)
  17. RCW 7.70.070
  18. RCW 4.16.350
  19. RCW 4.56.250 disposition (repealed 2023)
  20. RCW 70.02.080
  21. Bennett v. United States, Washington Supreme Court No. 101300-1 (2023)

Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

×

Free case review

Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.

No fees or costs unless we win
© 2026 Beverly Law. All rights reserved. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Free consultation
No fees or costs unless we win
Call Now · 24/7
4.8 out of 5 · 604 Google reviews
Skip to content