If a fat-freezing treatment left you with a firm, growing bulge instead of less fat, you may have a product liability claim against the device maker, and sometimes a separate claim against the clinic. California’s general injury deadline is two years (CCP 335.1); claims against a licensed provider follow CCP 340.5.
Questions about your injury case?
Leave your name and phone. We call you back today, in English or Spanish, and the consultation is free.
Free consultation · English y Español · No fees or costs unless we win
What is paradoxical adipose hyperplasia, and how often does it happen?
Cryolipolysis cools fat through the skin so that some fat cells die and the body clears them. Paradoxical adipose hyperplasia (PAH) is the opposite of the goal: the treated area grows. Physicians first reported it in JAMA Dermatology in 2014, describing a man whose abdomen developed a well-defined fatty mass about three months after one treatment cycle. That report put the incidence at 0.0051% and found no evidence that it goes away on its own.
Later studies found higher rates. A Texas practice reported 2 cases in 422 treatments (0.47%) in 2015, noting that PAH usually appears about three to six months after treatment; both patients chose liposuction. A 2021 review of 8,658 cycles at eight Canadian centers found rates between 0.05% and 0.39% per cycle, higher than the 0.025% figure the authors attribute to the manufacturer, and fewer cases with newer machines. A 2025 meta-analysis of 28 studies and 13,078 patients estimated a pooled incidence of 0.22%, about 1 in 455 patients, rated as low-certainty evidence, and called for fuller risk disclosure. These are research figures with their years; none of them tells you what happened in your own case.
What did the FDA clear, and what does MAUDE show?
The FDA granted a De Novo request for the first dermal cooling device for fat reduction in August 2010 (DEN090002). That decision created a Class II category with special controls, now 21 CFR 878.4340, and later versions reached the market through 510(k) clearances, the most recent in our search dated September 2024 (K233732). Clearance means the FDA found a device substantially equivalent to one already on the market. It does not decide whether a particular patient was warned well enough.
The FDA’s MAUDE database holds adverse event reports from manufacturers, clinics and patients. The FDA warns that these reports cannot be used to measure rates or prove that a device caused an event. When we checked the FDA’s current device safety communications list in November 2026, it did not include one about cryolipolysis.
Is this a product claim or a malpractice claim?
They are different claims against different defendants, and many cases involve both. A product claim says the device itself was defective or came with inadequate warnings. A malpractice claim says the person who used it fell below the standard of care, for example by skipping the history, treating someone the labeling warned against, or ignoring a growing mass at follow-up visits.
Who ran the machine matters. The Medical Board of California says offering medical procedures at a med spa is the practice of medicine, done by a physician or by a registered nurse or physician assistant under a physician who is immediately reachable. Texas lets a physician delegate a medical act to a trained person under supervision, and the physician stays responsible (Occupations Code 157.001). Washington requires the physician to take a history, examine the patient and get informed consent before authorizing a cosmetic procedure with a prescription device, and makes the physician “ultimately responsible” for safety (WAC 246-919-606).
Disappointing result or injury: where is the line?
Fat reduction varies from person to person, and the device can work as designed while you still dislike the result. The examples below are Example only; records and medical testimony decide real cases.
- Usually a disappointing result: the area shrank less than the brochure suggested, or a second session was needed for an even look.
- Possibly an injury: a firm, well-defined mass grew in the exact shape of the applicator months later, and a physician diagnosed PAH or recommended surgery to remove it.
- Possibly an injury: a burn, frostbite or nerve damage that a doctor ties to the treatment.
Free case review
Tell us what happened and where the claim stands. Our team reviews it and explains your options. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
What do product liability laws require in California, Texas and Washington?
California. A plaintiff must show a defendant made, distributed or sold the product and that it had a manufacturing defect, a design defect or inadequate warnings (CACI 1200). Design can be judged by what an ordinary consumer would expect (CACI 1203) or by weighing risks against benefits, where the defendant carries the burden once the plaintiff shows the design caused harm (CACI 1204). A warning claim turns on risks that were known or knowable under the science of the time, and in prescription drug and implant cases the warning runs to the prescribing physician (CACI 1205).
Texas. Chapter 82 covers claims against manufacturers and sellers on any theory (82.001). The statutory “safer alternative design” burden in 82.005 does not apply to drugs or devices as federal law defines them. The FDA-warnings presumption in 82.007 is written for pharmaceutical products, while 82.008 gives a rebuttable presumption to products that went through federal pre-market approval, and courts decide whether a given clearance fits that section.
Washington. Under RCW 7.72.030 a manufacturer is liable for harm from a product not reasonably safe in design or warnings, judged by negligence, and strictly liable for construction defects or broken warranties. A provider of professional services who uses products within the scope of practice is not a “product seller” (RCW 7.72.010), so a claim against the clinic follows the health care rules instead.
How long do you have to file?
| State | Against the device maker | Against the provider |
|---|---|---|
| California | 2 years (CCP 335.1) | 1 year from discovery or 3 years from injury, whichever comes first (CCP 340.5) |
| Texas | 2 years (CPRC 16.003); 15-year repose from sale (16.012) | 2 years, 10-year repose (CPRC 74.251); 60-day notice (74.051) |
| Washington | 3 years from discovering the harm and its cause (RCW 7.72.060) | 3 years from the act or 1 year from discovery, whichever is later (RCW 4.16.350) |
PAH shows up months after treatment, so the start date can be disputed. Count from the treatment date to be safe and talk to a lawyer before the earliest date runs.
What to do now
- See a board-certified physician who did not perform the treatment and ask for a written diagnosis.
- Request your complete chart, consent form, treatment log and the device model and applicator used.
- Take dated photos of the area from the same angles each month.
- Hold off on corrective surgery until you have documented the area, unless your doctor says it cannot wait.
- Report the event through FDA MedWatch if you choose.
- Call a lawyer before the earliest deadline in the table above.
Talk to us about your treatment
If the treated area grew or changed shape after fat freezing, call Beverly Law at (310) 552-6959 for a free, confidential review in English or Spanish. We will tell you plainly if what you describe sounds like a disappointing result rather than a claim. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Common questions
Does signing a consent form that listed PAH end my claim?
Not always. A listed risk can weaken a warning claim, but a design or manufacturing claim, or a claim that the provider ignored warning signs, can still stand. The wording and the date of the form matter.
Is a med spa responsible, or only the manufacturer?
It depends on who did what. A clinic may answer for its own care, and a physician who delegated the treatment stays responsible in Texas and Washington under the rules above.
Will the FDA clearance stop a lawsuit?
Clearance is a fact the defense will use, and in Texas it may raise a presumption under 82.008. It does not by itself decide whether the warnings you got were adequate.
Do you handle Texas cases?
Yes. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou.
Ask a question
Not ready to call? Write your question and a member of our team answers you. No cost and no commitment.
Did the treated area grow instead of shrink? Ask us. — Beverly Law
Free case review. We gather the records, deal with the insurance company and keep you informed in English or Spanish. You owe no fees or costs unless we win.
Related pages
Plastic Surgery Malpractice · Who can you sue for a defective product injury in California? · How long do you have to file a product liability claim in Washington? · Notice before suing for medical malpractice in California · Do you need an expert witness in Washington? · Law Blog
Talk to our team today
Leave your name and phone and tell us in one line what you need.
Sources
- FDA De Novo database, DEN090002 dermal cooling device (2010)
- FDA 510(k) database, K233732 (2024)
- 21 CFR 878.4340, Contact cooling system for aesthetic use
- FDA, About MAUDE
- FDA MAUDE database search
- FDA MedWatch safety reporting program
- FDA, Medical device safety communications
- Jalian et al., Paradoxical adipose hyperplasia after cryolipolysis, JAMA Dermatology 2014 (PubMed)
- Singh et al., Paradoxical adipose hyperplasia secondary to cryolipolysis, Lasers Surg Med 2015 (PubMed)
- Nikolis and Enright, multicenter evaluation of 8,658 cycles, Aesthet Surg J 2021 (PubMed)
- Mah et al., Incidence of PAH after cryolipolysis, systematic review and meta-analysis, 2025 (PubMed)
- CACI No. 1200, Strict Liability: Essential Factual Elements
- CACI No. 1203, Design Defect: Consumer Expectation Test
- CACI No. 1204, Design Defect: Risk-Benefit Test
- CACI No. 1205, Strict Liability: Failure to Warn
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 335.1
- Cal. Code of Civil Procedure 340.5
- Medical Board of California, Medical Spas
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 82 (82.001, 82.005, 82.007, 82.008)
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 16 (16.003, 16.012)
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code chapter 74 (74.001, 74.051, 74.251)
- Tex. Occupations Code chapter 157 (157.001)
- RCW 7.72.010
- RCW 7.72.030
- RCW 7.72.060
- RCW 4.16.350
- WAC 246-919-606, Nonsurgical medical cosmetic procedures
Important: This page is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Beverly Law. Laws change and every case is different; talk to a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. You owe no fees or costs unless we win. Texas cases are handled by the firm’s Texas-licensed attorneys, Joyce Ondich and John Efstathiou. Last reviewed: 2026-11-13.

